The problem? Roth had found a bowl containing brown M&Ms, which were explicitly forbidden in Van Halen's contract.
[When the band played "Ice Cream Man" at early Van Halen shows, Roth played his "Davesicle" -- a guitar in the shape of a Creamsicle.]
[In October 2003, Guinness rejected a California man's claim to have set a new world record for eating Smarties with chopsticks (115 in three minutes). Jim Hager was disqualified -- for using M&Ms instead.]